Soft Skills vs Hard Skills: What Should Matter More in Hiring?

Soft Skills vs Hard Skills: What Should Matter More in Hiring?

Job hunting is already stressful, and trying to strike the right balance between showing off your killer technical skills and sounding like the most emotionally intelligent team player? Even worse.

You’ve probably asked yourself this: What do employers care about more, my skills or my vibes? If you’ve ever obsessively Googled things like “top resume skills” or “why am I not getting interviews even though I’m qualified,” welcome to the club.

In the real hiring world, the line between hard skills and soft skills is blurrier than we like to admit. A certified data analyst might get the job interview, but it’s their communication, collaboration, and problem-solving abilities that help them actually land and thrive in the role.

A LinkedIn Global Talent Trends report confirms it: 92% of talent professionals say soft skills are just as important, or more important, than hard skills when hiring. In fact, Testlify argues that in a rapidly evolving job market, technical skills may get outdated quickly, but soft skills are what keep employees adaptable and resilient.

So what’s the real difference between these two, and which should matter more in your next hiring decision (or job application)?

What’s the Real Difference Between Hard and Soft Skills?

Hard skills and soft skills are like the engine and the steering wheel of your career. You need both, but they do very different jobs.

Hard skills are the technical, teachable things, stuff you usually learn through courses, training, or certifications. Think: writing code, using Photoshop, managing a budget, operating machinery, or writing SEO content. These are measurable and often listed plainly on a CV or LinkedIn profile.

They’re also the first filter. Most companies still use ATS (Applicant Tracking Systems) to scan for hard skill keywords before a human even reads your application. That’s why it’s important to still include them explicitly. According to Indeed, listing specific proficiencies like Excel, CRM software, or graphic design tools increases your chances of being shortlisted.

Soft skills, on the other hand, are all about how you work. Things like emotional intelligence, communication, time management, adaptability, creativity, leadership, and teamwork. Unlike hard skills, these are harder to measure, but they’re what make people actually want to work with you.

A great example? A 2024 LinkedIn Workplace Learning Report noted that managers now value soft skills like communication, adaptability, and emotional intelligence more than ever, especially in hybrid or remote settings.

Even Harvard Business Review points out that resilience, empathy, and flexibility are critical soft skills in leadership and collaboration, particularly during change-heavy times (hello, post-pandemic world).

In today’s job market, especially in people-facing roles or leadership positions, soft skills aren’t the cherry on top, they’re the whole cake.

Why Soft Skills Matter More (and Might Even Be the Dealbreaker)

No matter how many certifications or technical achievements you have, you won’t go far if you can’t work well with people.

Yes, hard skills open the door, but soft skills decide if you’ll be invited to stay.

Data backs this up. According to a Wonderlic study, 93% of employers say soft skills are an essential, or very important, factor in hiring decisions. Even Google, during its now-famous “Project Oxygen” study, discovered that the top predictors of high-performing teams weren’t technical. They were psychological safety, empathy, and communication, all soft skills (source).

Let’s not forget real-world proof. Companies like Shake Shack and Blackstone are openly prioritizing human skills over degrees or technical prowess. As reported by Business Insider, Blackstone’s CEO Jonathan Gray values “empathy and judgment” just as much as deal-making skills.

Also, soft skills are often what enable hard skills to even shine. What’s the point of being a killer backend developer if you can’t explain your logic to the frontend team or worse, you refuse to work with them?

Even industries that used to be hyper-focused on technical knowledge, like engineering or IT, are shifting. CuraHR notes that in modern tech teams, collaboration, openness to feedback, and adaptability are becoming key hiring criteria, not nice-to-haves.

People with a blend of both strong hard and soft skills can earn up to 40% more than their peers, according to The Interview Guys.

Industry Variations – When Hard Skills Still Take the Lead

While soft skills are rising stars, some industries still prioritize hard skills, especially in the early stages of recruitment.

If you’re applying for roles in engineering, data science, finance, or healthcare, your resume must scream technical proficiency. Employers want to see if you can code in Python, interpret medical imaging, or use Tableau with your eyes closed. These hard skills are the non-negotiables. For instance, in cybersecurity or machine learning, it’s not enough to say “I’m a fast learner.” You need to show technical experience through certifications like CompTIA Security+ or hands-on portfolio work (TechTarget explains this well).

However, even in technical industries, your ability to collaborate, communicate and solve problems cross-functionally is a huge differentiator. According to Testlify, tech companies like Google and Meta now prioritize a soft skill–driven culture. Why? Because innovation happens faster when people share ideas, work across teams, and adapt quickly.

On the flip side, if you’re in marketing, sales, human resources, social work, or customer service, soft skills are your bread and butter. A stunning portfolio will get your foot in the door, sure. But empathy, active listening, and negotiation are what close deals and retain clients. HubSpot notes that top-performing salespeople have higher emotional intelligence than average.

The weight you give to soft vs. hard skills should reflect your target industry. But regardless of where you fall, employers expect you to come in with both.

What Hiring Managers Are Actually Looking For

Let’s decode what recruiters really want, because they’re not just looking at your resume; they’re looking through it.

According to a recent LinkedIn Talent Blog, recruiters consistently list communication, adaptability, time management, and critical thinking among the most in-demand soft skills. In fact, their top takeaway was: “Soft skills can make or break a hire.”

A 2024 survey by Cornerstone Staffing also revealed that while technical expertise gets you in the door, it’s the “people and project fit” that wins offers. Employers are now designing multi-layered interview processes that screen for cultural alignment, emotional intelligence, and team collaboration not just technical aptitude.

Let’s say you’re applying for a product manager role. Sure, you’ll need to show knowledge of tools like Jira, Agile methodology, or SQL. But they’ll also want to know how you negotiate with stakeholders, prioritize under pressure, and give feedback without sparking a war.

As Harvard Business School emphasizes, forward-thinking companies are designing training programs to develop technical skills in-house, but they’re still struggling to train for empathy, integrity, and leadership. That’s why they’re hiring for those first.

How to Measure Soft Skills (Because It’s Not Just a Vibe Check)

How do you actually measure soft skills in hiring?

Unlike hard skills, which can be assessed through tests or certifications, soft skills are often intangible and open to bias. But that doesn’t mean we can’t measure them at all.

Recruiters now rely on behavioral interviewing frameworks like the STAR Method, Situation, Task, Action, Result, to draw out real examples of soft skill usage. For example, instead of asking, “Are you a good communicator?”, they’ll ask: “Tell me about a time you had to resolve a team conflict.” That’s how they assess your conflict resolution, empathy, and communication in one go (Indeed explains STAR interviews here).

Some companies go further. They use personality assessments, like the DiSC profile or Big 5 traits, to gauge emotional intelligence and leadership style. Others incorporate job simulations, where candidates perform tasks under real-world pressure to assess adaptability and collaboration skills.

Even AI is stepping in. Tools like HireVue analyze tone, word choice, and micro-expressions in interviews to detect communication ability and confidence.

Of course, nothing replaces human intuition. That’s why companies still rely on multiple rounds of interviews, team interviews, and reference checks to verify that what you say aligns with how you actually show up.

The Hiring Sweet Spot – Blending Both Skill Types

Here’s the secret sauce: it’s not a competition between soft and hard skills. The best hires bring both to the table and know when to lead with each.

Imagine a triangle: at one corner is technical competence, another is emotional intelligence, and the third is cultural fit. The sweet spot? People who hit all three. That’s where hiring ROI explodes, team friction drops, and performance soars.

In fact, a World Economic Forum report ranked analytical thinking, resilience, and flexibility (all soft skills) as top capabilities for 2025, right alongside data analysis and tech literacy. This means that the future of hiring isn’t about choosing sides. It’s about finding people who can code and collaborate, analyze and empathize, lead and listen.

Companies like Amazon, Google, and Netflix openly design their hiring rubrics to score both skill sets equally. As Google’s re:Work found, the most effective employees aren’t always the smartest in the room—they’re the most self-aware.

So whether you’re hiring, or job hunting, the real question isn’t “which skill matters more?” It’s: “how well can I balance both?”

Candidate Action Plan – How to Showcase Both Soft & Hard Skills

So, how do you bring this all together when you’re job hunting or building your portfolio?

Audit Your Skill Set

Start by separating your skills into two buckets:

  • Hard Skills: E.g. Data analysis, project management tools, UI/UX design, foreign languages, copywriting, etc.
  • Soft Skills: E.g. Empathy, conflict resolution, adaptability, time management, creativity.

Use tools like Skill Matcher by Indeed or LinkedIn’s Skill Assessment to identify what you’re strong in—and what’s missing.

Strengthen What’s Weak

Use the STAR Method Everywhere

Don’t just tell recruiters you’re a problem-solver or great under pressure. Prove it.
Whether it’s your CV, cover letter, or interviews, use the STAR technique (breakdown here):

  • Situation
  • Task
  • Action
  • Result

This storytelling framework makes your soft skills come alive and shows you think critically and reflectively.

Create a Skills-Backed Portfolio

A portfolio isn’t just for designers and developers. Even if you’re a social worker, marketer, or project manager, a case study portfolio can go a long way.

Include:

  • Slide decks from projects
  • Process notes showing your leadership or team collaboration
  • Testimonials from clients, co-workers, or mentors
  • Screenshots or outcomes of your work (campaign analytics, design mockups, reports)

This kind of evidence shows off both hard and soft skills in context—and that’s what hiring managers want.

Use Keywords Strategically

When writing your resume or LinkedIn profile, use keywords that reflect both skill types. For instance:

  • “Led a cross-functional team of 5 using Agile methods to deliver a client project 2 weeks early”, shows leadership + time management + technical knowledge
  • “Conducted UX research using surveys and interviews to design a high-converting landing page (18% increase in sign-ups)”, shows data literacy + communication + problem-solving

Recruiters search for these keywords. Don’t miss out by being vague.

Why Balance Is the Secret Weapon in Hiring (and in Career Growth)

Here’s the truth that too many people overlook: you don’t need to choose between soft and hard skills, you need to build a bridge between them.

Hard skills might get you in the door. But soft skills are what get you promoted, trusted, and remembered.

Employers are looking for humans who bring more than their tools, they want collaborators, critical thinkers, and people who make teams better just by being part of them.

Whether you’re a job seeker or a hiring manager, the takeaway is simple:

Don’t undervalue technical expertise but never underestimate the power of human skills.

Looking to build a workforce that gets it right from day one? At Anutio, we match companies with professionals who bring both competence and character. Let’s talk about how we can support your hiring strategy. Explore our platform and build smarter teams, one balanced hire at a time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *